You will be presented with two pairs of
essays. From each pair, you will select one essay to write.
The essay is a writing exercise. Accordingly, you should compose
your answer in narrative format. Not bullets. Not an outline. Instead
well-constructed paragraphs that conform to the rules of English
style and composition.
Your essay should be argumentative. Stake a claim early in your
essay, formulate it clearly as a thesis statement, and then spend
the rest of the essay defending that claim with specific reference
to the course texts and lectures. Remember that a blank sheet of
paper is worth zero points. Your task is to fill it up with points.
1. Territorial Nation-State: From the late Middle Ages
to the twentieth century the European state was transformed from
a system of personal loyalties to a territorial unit with a centralized
federal administration. Discuss three items in relation to this:
a) the process of centralization, using a specific state as an
example; b) the motivations (military, economic, religious, political)
that led successive administrations to bring power to a central
location; c) the social or cultural consequences of the rise of
the territorial nation-state. Then answer this question: Is the
territorial nation state normative (i.e. is it right, natural,
proper that human society should be organized according to such
boundaries)? What other ways might humanity organize itself? How
has society been organized before or outside of modern Europe?
2. The Arts: We have spent considerable time on art
in this course: literature in antiquity, the early middle ages,
and modernity; music from monophonic chant to modern symphony;
visual art from ancient Greek idealization to Renaissance perspective
and modern art. Using the images, music, and literature you have
experienced in this course, discuss some of the ways we can use
the arts to gain access to the past. Be sure to include specific
examples of the values and ideas conveyed in specific works of
art.
3. Resistance: Following the St. Bartholomew’s
Day massacre in 1572, there emerged in Europe a political discourse
regarding the location of political sovereignty and the circumstances
under which the citizen might resist or even overthrow that sovereign.
Making specific references to the texts discussed in this course,
describe some of those political ideologies. Cite texts approving
the right of citizens to reform their government as well as texts
that denied that right. Discuss also some of the ways in which
those ideologies were manifested in European political events.
4. Reason, or not: Beginning with the Reformation in
the sixteenth century and continuing through nineteenth-century
industrialization, Europe looked with growing confidence on its
own progress. What evidence was there for European progress? What
evidence was there that such progress was illusory? Who were the
harbingers of irrational forces, and what was their message?
5. The Church: During the thirteenth century the Church
stood at the peak of its power as the "papal monarchy."
Thereafter it underwent a series of crises that culminated in
the Protestant Reformation and beyond. Describe the narrative
of church history from the fourteenth to the seventeenth century.
What were some of the social consequences of the splitting of
the church? And what was really at stake behind all the violence
and conflict?